Radiant Return
  • Blog
  • Author
  • Contact

Civil Discourse

10/14/2016

6 Comments

 
Kindness is like water and religion is like tea. We can live without tea but not without water.
- Dalai Lama


I came to the USA over 41 years ago as a student, and thus have spent more than two-thirds of my life here. While I have maintained my connections with my roots through family, religion and culture, I also consider myself a patriot and true American, one who is proud of my citizenship. However, I have been disturbed as to the current civil discourse, not having seen such hurtful and hate-inciting actions in this arena before. Internet, texting, twitter-posting and other modes have become convenient tools for putting others down.

While this extends beyond politics, let’s start there. I have felt that Mr. Trump paints a dark picture of America, and *very* rarely shares good thoughts or kind words (though I was pleasantly surprised at his recent compliment to Hillary Clinton regarding her fighting nature in the second debate). Hillary Clinton’s secretive nature and perceived lying and “cold” demeanor has bred distrust.

To add to the mess, the media has changed the landscape of political news, trying to increase the drama factor. MSNBC, CNN and FOX are purveyors of different kinds of snake oils, and I find it disturbing the impact that the press can have on our public, without always being reliable. I lament the bygone days of Walter Cronkite, Peter Jennings, and Robert Mcneil, when you could hang your hat on the nightly news, but unfortunately our society needs more “entertainment.”

Anger and hate are infectious and they need to be guided with kindness, understanding and compassion. In the current political atmosphere, both sides are playing nefarious games which have the potential of unraveling the moral fabric of our beautiful country. We are not too far from doing the irreparable damage and completely losing the spirit of our founders.

Gandhi once said that if you have a bad government, then you deserve it.  This is especially true in a democracy. Our government and leaders, to a large extent, reflect our collective thought process. If we look into the mirror of our collective thought process, we will see how coarse, judgmental, and disrespectful our language has become. We are enveloped by the fear of unknown of “others” to the extent that rational thinking has no seat. It is said that the illusion of knowledge is worse than ignorance. Our ignorance is further compounded by the media and campaign dances of smoke and mirrors.

I wonder how we managed to travel so far without realizing that we had lost our way. We have conveniently divided ourselves into enemy camps of Republicans and Democrats. Tribal affinity is so strong that each person belonging to his/her party is not willing to give up his/her prism. The vote along party lines in the past few elections has become a norm. These days, when a leader expresses that he/she is considering voting outside of their party, he/she gets twitter abuses and sometimes mortal threats. An empire rests on the shoulders of its leaders, who in turn are dependent on the citizens for navigational vision. We need to ask ourselves: is his the vision we want, a country divided along party lines, racial fault lines, economic lines? I have seen the results of this kind of poisonous brew in India. Indians are still internally fighting hate inspired battles which were started 1000 years ago. The partition of India has not cured the disease. Love and understanding requires work. Hate revolution is easy to start, and it may give the desired results to some people in power, but the country suffers for hundreds of years.

Sometimes when I reflect on the current situation, I am under a waking nightmarish vision and fear that we are slipping into a slow, simmering decay. The words that Chief Sealth (1855) uttered after his defeat reverberate in me:
Tribe follows tribe and nation follows nation, like the waves of the sea,
It is order of nations and regret is useless,
Your time of decay may be distant but it will surely come,
For even the white man whose God walked and talked with him
As friend with friend, cannot be exempt from common destiny,
We may be brothers afterall, we will see.   
 

My optimism forces me to think that we will overcome the division and negativity that currently plagues our political and civil arenas. My hope is that even in the remainder of this campaign, respect will prevail. My hope is that whoever gets elected will not only heal the divide but show the world that we have not lost the virtues taught to us by our founding fathers and visionaries. In the meantime, let us start a civil discourse with the “other” person. Let us be kind in language. Somebody said that be kind to others for you may not know that they may be fighting graver battle than yours. Let us practice catching those unkind hurtful words in the throat before they escape. Let us brake the walls of tribalism and have a civil dialogue. In the spirit of universal brotherhood (an essential tenet the Sikh religion), I am leaving you with the following poem:
I sought my God, My God I could not see,
I sought my soul, My soul eluded me
I sought my brother, and found all three.
-Anonymous

   

6 Comments
Harbir S. Bhalla
10/16/2016 09:35:17 am

Very well articulated thoughts...

Reply
Adam
10/16/2016 10:44:24 am

Hi Paul,

Thanks for publishing your thoughts. They strike me as insightful, kind and wise. I believe in brotherhood and treating your neighbor as you wish to be treated.
The political problem right now is that politeness and decorum are being used as a cover to disenfranchise American citizens from their livelihood. The concept of citizenship, which means that we're all in this together as Americans each with one vote, has been deeply violated by our business and political leaders who have offshored their profits and jobs to the detriment of millions of our countrymen and women. Simulataneously they have flooded our shores with opium. This is something that respectful leaders in previous generations did not engage in.
We are in a tough situation in this country, and not everyone has the education and eloquence to express their needs in the politically correct dialect that the media and establishment insists upon. The decorum that the powerful chastise others for lacking while they decimate the livelihoods of millions of Americans through offshoring, and simultaneously instigate dangerous conflicts abroad that result in hundreds of thousands of violent deaths and millions of lives ruined, may be violated, but is that really what's most deserving of focus? You can not marginalize nearly half of America and then insist on polite discourse, when after thirty years of unaccounted for damage, people start to speak up for themselves. Just because they can't express themselves eloquently, or they are flailing about with emotions, doesn't mean their voices deserve to be silenced. Just because they're not talented or highly intelligent or successful doesn't mean they lose the rights of citizenship.
England is known for royalty, politeness and decorum. But America has always been a bit rough around the edges. Especially Philadelphia. This is a painful time for our country and I wish everyone would read your words of advice.

Reply
Indu
11/1/2016 01:27:40 pm

Dear Paul
I am always enraptured with your writings..the depth and detail takes me right to the setting of the story or incident that you are writing about.
Ascending and descending are part of our lives ..beautiful lesson learnt from Guru Gobind Singh ji. "Death is perplexed by the audacity of us being alive after what we've gone through"...no words to describe the incredible play of words to get the message across. Learnt so much about Guru Gobind Singh ji.

So many things and details in this blog have totally blown me away. I could go on and on.

Kindness as a way of life is essential to all of us in this planet.
Acceptance of what happens in life as God's will.

Love all your blogs Paul..please keep writing. They reflect what a wonderful soul you are and I feel blessed to know more about you each time you write a blog.

Reply
downloadpopcorntimeapk.com link
12/10/2018 02:05:27 pm

Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss . Don't know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

Reply
desksta link
5/16/2020 06:35:32 am

Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post

Reply
celebrity birthdays link
6/28/2022 07:46:22 am

Fantastic review, I'm positive you happen to be obtaining a my page outstanding response.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    About Radiant Return

    I will be using this blog to share my thoughts on human nature, philosophy, and religion. 

    I hope you share your thoughts as well.

    Thanks,
    Paul
Proudly powered by Weebly